Posts Tagged ‘police officers’

Imminent Fall of Nitish Govt? Part II

Sunday, December 20th, 2009



Since my last post, I have been looking for media reports to cite examples of achievements of Nitish Govt. However, everyday I get the news mostly similar to what I mentioned in the last post. May be that the negative and unusual events make the hot news.

Nitish Govt completed 4 years in office on 24th November, 2009 and the highlights of government version of its achievements have appeared in the press. I have also tried to gather some informal impressions from “table talk” in my social gatherings. In general, people appear to believe that:

* Law and order is relatively in better shape. People are less afraid of going out or travelling in odd hours.

* Significant increase in the number of children being enrolled in schools.
The official figure says that out of 25 lakh children out of school, 15 lakh have been enrolled during the last 4 years. In the same period, the student to teacher ratio has been brought down from 78:1 to 58:1.

* Significant improvement in health services including availability of doctors and supporting staff in primary and district hospitals.
The official report says the average patient turn out has increased from 39 to 4500 patients per month per health center during the last 4 years. In the same period, institutional delivery has increased from 45000 to 3.12 lakh resulting in significant decline in maternal mortality rate. [unfortunately the patient turn out data does not seem to match with earlier published data]

* Condition of roads in Bihar is comparatively better now. Construction of new roads, widening of existing roads and construction of bridges have remained a major focus of the government to develop the road network in the state.
The official data shows that some 117 bridges and culverts, and 2018.97 Km of road were constructed in the last 4 years. The plan outlay for road construction increased from Rs.133.85 cr to Rs.2489.15 cr.

There are many more things which can be written from the official reports regarding government’s achievements. I leave it to others to highlight them. But one thing is certain that the image of Bihar has changed from a non-performing to performing and growing state.

I am reminded of Chandra Babu Naidu who is regarded as the architect of modern Andhra Pradesh. Inspite of large scale development and modernization, Chandra Babu Naidu lost the elections. I am not competent to comment on political debacles, but any government not able to mitigate the sufferings of common people is bound to lose in the long run. I sometimes wonder how Patna, the capital city of a poor state, saw the affluence of Patna people with some 1700 cars and 300 Kg of gold being sold this Diwali, how people are aquiring wealth several times the salary they receive in their lifetime, and so on OR is it simply the index of developing Bihar.

The achievements of Nitish Govt is well demonstrated by “Economic Times Man of the Year Award” and “Politician of the Year Award” to be conferred on Nitish Kumar in January next. Nitish Kumar however admits that his efforts are negated by rampant corruption from top to bottom in state bureaucracy. But if the common man of the state is getting the benefit of development and is happy, there is no case for imminent fall of Nitish Govt. The development statistics must correlate to aspirations and happiness of the majority residing in the state.

Dr P R Prasad, Patna

Imminent Fall of Nitish Govt? Part I

Thursday, November 5th, 2009



I am not talking here anything about politics. I am just discussing what the media is saying now-a-days about the administration of Nitish Govt which has been widely known as “Sushasan” and if it has delivered the expected results to alleviate the sufferings of common man in Bihar.

Recently, I had the opportunity to watch some news clippings on ETV Bihar which, I think, are worthy of being mentioned here. The first one relates to CM’s meeting with the police officers of Bihar. Nitish Kumar was shown saying - “Previously police officers wanted to work but the then government did not support, now the present government wants and it is police officers’ turn to work“. The commentary with the clipping however said that Nitish Kumar was saying this to the police officers for quite some time but no one heeded him.

The second clipping on the same TV channel showed that in Patna secretariat offices, even at around 10.30 AM, not only most of the senior bureaucrats were found absent, but the subordinate staff seats were also empty. The channel reporter wondered if the state will ever develop with this type of sincerity and attitude.

In yet another clipping, the same TV channel showed that Bihar stands at bottom of the development ladder according to a survey report and it remains at the same position where it stood in the regime of Lalu/Rabri. This belies the claim that Bihar has developed in Nitish Govt regime.

In an article “Agenda, issues and challenges for Bihar” by Amitabh Srivastava published in India Today, Dy Chief Minister Sushil Modi has been quoted saying - “Bihar has huge shortage of about 700 officers in the state civil services rank alone, almost half of the Bihar’s blocks are currently manned though stop-gap arrangements, deputy collectors are doubling as circle officers, the state is equally short of IAS officers, many from the available lot of IAS officers are willing for central deputation but not in backing the political leadership in Bihar …”.

Now look at the recent newspaper reports about higher education scenario in the state. HR Dept of Bihar Govt issues order for inspection of all colleges and universities by its officers in “public interest” as these institutions are run on “public money”. Governor-cum-Chancellor issues directives that in all academic and administrative matters, the colleges and universities have to comply by the directives of Chancellor only as per the relevant acts. HR Dept stops the salary of Bhagalpur Univ VC for non-compliance of its orders. Another case is worth mentioning. Following UGC recommendations to raise the retirement age of teachers to 65 years, Bihar Govt rejected it on the ground that education is a state subject and the UGC recommendation is not binding on the state. High Court had to reject the government plea on the ground that the benefit of retirement age as recommended by UGC has accrued on the basis of legislative provision which cannot be denied by executive orders.

Whosoever is at fault, the law will take care. But one thing is apparent that all is not well with the universities and the higher education in the state. Further, medical colleges are under the threat of derocgnition by MCI for not meeting the minimum requirements, what to talk of excellence in medical education. Health Dept officials say that they are doing the needful in the matter. Same thing that we are hearing for decades. Most of the courses in Engg Colleges are yet to be accredited.

These are just some examples of what media is telling people about the constraints under which Nitish Govt is trying to push Bihar up the ladder of development. What has been written above is just what captured my attention and it immediately gives the impression that nothing is well with the Govt. Does it really mean that Govt has done nothing good so far and its fall is imminent?

Not exactly. Inspite of constraints, many good work has been done by Nitish Govt. We will talk about some of the things in the 2nd part of this post. To be continued …

Dr P R Prasad, Patna