Archive for April, 2010

Who Will Punish You - God? OR Law?

Sunday, April 25th, 2010



In a recent news article, it is reported that a property/piece of land of Bhikhamdas Ram Janki Thakurwadi in Kadamkuan, Patna, belonging to BSBRT, was in illegal and forceful occupation of the disciples of Godman Asaram Bapu. When the officials went to execute the court order to get the property freed from their illegal occupation, Asaram’s followers tried to scare them with godman’s curse. They also allegedly assaulted a constable of Kadamkuan Police Station and the Superintenedent of BSBRT. Asaram Bapu has also been reportedly threatening people in his televised religious discourses with divine displeasure for disobeying him.

Mr Kishore Kunal, a former IPS officer and presently the Administrator of Bihar State Board of Religious Trusts (BSBRT) has filed a case in a local court in Patna against Asaram Bapu, his disciples Swami Narendra Goswami and Jai Kumar Singh under Indian Penal Code Section 120(B)[criminal conspiracy], Section 500[defamation] and Section 508[inducing a person to believe that he will be doomed by divine man's curse, if he did not follow the divine man].

The local court in Patna has taken cognizance of the charges against Asaram Bapu and his disciples, and has issued summons for them to appear in the court and explain their stand on May 22, 2010.

What has captured my attention in this case is the Section 508 of IPC. I do not have much understanding of this legal provision, but whatever has appeared in the press, it follows that it is a criminal offence if a divine man curses you [gives you "Shraap"] to be doomed for not obeying his legal or illegal dictates.

It is also reported that Mr Kishore Kunal takes a very tough stand against ‘Godmen’ who exploit people in the name of religion. He says, “Exploitation of followers by so-called godmen, including sexual exploitation of women, after threatening them with divine displeasure is an open secret. People should come forward and use this legal provision to bring such exploiters to book.”

It is perhaps for the first time in the country that this legal provision has been invoked. Your faith in God or Divine man is OK and it is a matter of personal choice, but you must also have faith in the law of the land. If anyone works against the law in the name of God, he or she will be punished by the law without any consideration of the divine displeasure. It is my firm belief that if you are tutored to work against the law, it cannot be the “divine teaching”.

The provisions of Section 508 of IPC are not known to many. It is our duty to spread this information to masses to protect them from exploitations in the name of GOD.

Dr P R Prasad, Patna

IIT-JEE: Big Letdown for Hindi Medium Students

Sunday, April 18th, 2010



Recently, I came across a news item on the above heading published in Hindustan Times, Patna Edition. It says that there was a big mistake (blunder) in the Hindi versions of just concluded IIT-JEE 2010 question papers specially with regard to distribution of marks and printed instructions. This is likely to jeopardize the prospects of a large number of students belonging to Hindi belt, ie. Bihar, Jharkhand, UP, MP, Rajasthan etc.

Anand Kumar of Super 30 has reportedly said that such mistakes will ruin the prospects of students of rural background and government schools and for them it is a big letdown. He has also demanded that the JEE should consider taking re-examination. Chief Minister Nitish Kumar has also taken up the matter with Union HRD Minister Kapil Sibal who has assured to look into the matter and that no student will be allowed to suffer on account of error in question papers.

Students, mostly from rural background, are protesting and are genuinely concerned about their future. IIT-JEE organizing committee however says that there are only “minor mistakes” here and there in the question papers. The committee has assured that these “mistakes” will be taken care of at the evaluation stage and the performance of the students will not be affected.

While I do not know what will be the fate of Hindi medium examinees, any mistake in the question paper must be addressed through re-examination only. Students’ performances in examinations are very much dependent on the material and the options available in the question papers. This is particularly true in examinations like IIT-JEE where every student tries to outperform the other to get a seat in IIT and in the process suffers severe mental tension during the examination. Mistakes in Hindi question papers cannot ensure level-playing field for the students to compete.

However, in my opinion the very concept of Hindi and English, two different versions of question papers, is not in the best interest of students. A Hindi medium student is definitely more comfortable in answering questions in Hindi, but after all he takes the examination in Hindi to study in an institute which teaches in English. The medium of instruction in IITs is not Hindi and therefore the students are forced to come out of the language comfort zone and, study and take further examinations at IITs in English only.

My intention is not to initiate any debate on Hindi vrs English, but my only suggestion is that the teaching in schools should be so oriented that students aspiring for IITs or the like institutions are made comfortable in writing examinations in English and there is nothing like Hindi version in IIT-JEE, unless IITs switch over to Hindi also as the medium of instruction.

Dr P R Prasad, Patna